AlesiaBoard

Imagine a world where every day, a nation's right to exist is questioned, its citizens live in constant fear of attack, and children are raised amid the deafening sound of sirens and explosions. This is the reality Israel faces—a democratic state surrounded by relentless threats, struggling not just to survive but to protect its people and way of life. In the wake of the horrific attacks on October 7, 2023, supporting Israel in this conflict is not merely a stance; it’s a moral imperative for those who believe in freedom, justice, and the fundamental right to peace.

In light of these attacks, the only viable path to lasting peace in the Levant requires the international community to offer Israel full and unequivocal support in dismantling Hamas, securing the safe return of hostages, and re-establishing stability for both Israeli and Palestinian civilians. By eliminating a terrorist organization that has perpetuated violence and destabilization, Israel can pave the way for genuine peace efforts that respect the rights and safety of all people in the region.

Israel’s Isolation and Need for Support

Israel’s struggle for survival has always been compounded by its isolation on the world stage, leaving it vulnerable in moments of crisis. Despite Israel's diplomatic and strategic efforts, it has historically faced opposition within the United Nations and other international bodies, where it is often unfairly singled out and condemned. As John Podhoretz notes, this "splendid isolation" is a legacy that stems from the aftermath of the 1967 Six-Day War, when Israel’s military successes met with swift, restrictive UN resolutions that have only grown in intensity over the years. Even today, as it defends its citizens from acts of terror, Israel faces an international community slow to recognize its right to security and justice.

This pattern of isolation makes it imperative that those who believe in human rights and the right to self-defense provide Israel with full, unequivocal support to dismantle Hamas, whose unprovoked acts of terror violate every principle of peace and dignity. The world must not repeat the mistakes of the past by standing passively on the sidelines; instead, it should act decisively to support Israel, breaking the cycle of isolation and helping to secure a future of peace in the Levant.

An Existential Threat: The Broader Conflict with Iran

Securing Israel’s future is crucial not only for its own stability but also for peace in a region fraught with complex, escalating threats. This need for security becomes even more pressing when considering the broader forces aligned against Israel, including one of its most formidable adversaries: Iran. As Shaul Bartal explores in The Iran-Israel War and the Clash of Civilizations, the conflict with Iran is not simply a bilateral struggle but a clash with far-reaching ideological and geopolitical implications. With Iran’s support for Hamas and other hostile proxies, Israel faces a relentless adversary intent on undermining its existence and destabilizing the region. Recognizing this context is essential to understanding why Israel’s efforts to neutralize threats like Hamas are part of a larger strategy to counter the influence of an adversarial regime committed to its destruction.

Iran’s involvement reveals the true scale of the threat Israel faces—an existential battle against forces committed to its destruction. Given this context, Israel’s right to self-defense is not only justified but necessary, as it confronts not merely Hamas, but an entire network of adversaries that endanger its citizens and the region. Full international support for Israel’s security efforts is essential, as it defends not just its own borders but the prospect of stability and peace in the Middle East.

Humanitarian Concerns: A Counter Perspective

While Israel’s right to defend itself is a key pillar of its security policy, it is essential to consider the humanitarian impacts of its actions on Palestinian civilians in Gaza. Critics argue that Israel’s military response to threats, particularly in densely populated areas like Gaza, has resulted in significant civilian suffering and raises concerns about human rights obligations. In their article, Humanitarian Crisis and Crumbling Pillars of R2P in Gaza, Humaira Shafi Awan and Hiba Malik underscore the devastating humanitarian toll that Israel’s security measures impose on the Palestinian population, challenging the notion that such actions align with the international community’s Responsibility to Protect (R2P) framework.

According to Awan and Malik, the situation in Gaza constitutes a humanitarian crisis where the pillars of R2P—preventing atrocities, reacting responsibly, and rebuilding peace—are compromised by military operations that, in their view, often lack adequate regard for civilian protection. They argue that indiscriminate attacks or blockades, even when aimed at neutralizing militant threats, strain the basic living conditions of Palestinian civilians, depriving them of essential resources and undermining their fundamental rights. From this perspective, critics assert that Israel’s self-defense efforts must be balanced by a duty to minimize harm to non-combatants, particularly in an area where civilians are inevitably impacted by the close proximity of militant targets.

A Powerful Rebuttal: The Realities of Terrorist Tactics

While the humanitarian concerns raised in critiques of Israel’s self-defense measures are valid, they overlook critical context that reshapes the understanding of responsibility and moral clarity in this conflict. Tomer Dekel, in A Contextless Context: Postcolonial Studies and Terrorism in Israel and Gaza, exposes how postcolonial narratives applied to Israel and Gaza often obscure the reality of terrorism by equating a democratic state’s right to defend its citizens with the actions of terrorist organizations that exploit their own people for strategic gain. Dekel’s analysis makes it clear that the portrayal of Israel’s defensive measures as oppressive ignores the deliberate, cynical tactics employed by Hamas—an organization that places military infrastructure within civilian areas precisely to shield itself from reprisal and to weaponize international sympathy when civilians are inevitably harmed.

Dekel further argues that this "contextless context" fuels a false equivalency that undermines Israel’s legitimate right to protect its citizens, disregarding the calculated methods used by Hamas to provoke civilian casualties as a form of asymmetric warfare. By hiding rocket launchers, weapons depots, and militant operatives within schools, hospitals, and residential areas, Hamas effectively denies the very humanitarian protections it claims to seek for Palestinians. Dekel’s insight makes it evident that any calls for restraint in Israel’s self-defense must account for the inherent challenges of responding to an enemy that uses human shields as a cornerstone of its strategy.

A truly balanced approach to the Israel-Gaza conflict must recognize that Israel is not simply confronting a local militant threat but a sophisticated and morally bankrupt strategy that uses humanitarian concerns as both shield and weapon. By exposing Hamas’s tactics and recognizing Israel’s need to respond decisively to protect its people, Dekel’s analysis dismantles the narrative that Israel’s actions contravene humanitarian standards. Instead, it becomes clear that full support for Israel’s efforts is the only way to ensure both the protection of Israeli lives and, ultimately, the liberation of Palestinian civilians from a regime that consistently sacrifices their well-being for political gain.

A Call to Action: The Last Line of Defense

As the world witnesses Israel’s struggle against terrorism and the pursuit of peace, it is clear that this is more than just a fight for one nation’s survival. It is a test of our collective commitment to justice, freedom, and the values we hold dear. In her essay, YOU ARE THE LAST LINE of DEFENSE, Bari Weiss reminds us that today’s youth are not merely observers but the final guardians of these ideals. The young generation stands as the last line of defense for truth and moral clarity in a world clouded by propaganda and oversimplified narratives.

Now more than ever, it is vital for young people to recognize the stakes and stand with Israel in its rightful pursuit of security and peace. This support goes beyond political alliances; it is a matter of standing for a future where nations can exist without fear, where human rights are protected, and where terrorism has no place. By embracing this responsibility, today’s youth have the power to influence a future that values courage, truth, and integrity. Let us be unwavering in our support for Israel and our rejection of terrorism, understanding that the fight for Israel’s survival is, ultimately, a fight for the values we want to see preserved in the world. The call is clear: stand up, speak out, and be the line of defense that ensures a legacy of peace and justice for generations to come.

Today, more than ever, our society grapples with the question: does religion still matter? Many would say no, arguing that faith is outdated in a world of science, progress, and technology. Yet, to dismiss religion as irrelevant ignores its profound influence and the positive role it continues to play in modern society. Judeo-Christian values, in particular, form the moral backbone of Western civilization, shaping everything from our legal systems to our sense of justice and compassion. Far from being obsolete, religion—especially the Judeo-Christian tradition—is a force for stability, ethical grounding, community, and identity.

In an age marked by division and a loss of shared values, religion’s timeless teachings hold essential answers.

Judeo-Christian Morals: The Foundation of Society’s Ethical Compass

Judeo-Christian beliefs have provided a solid moral framework for centuries, guiding both individual actions and societal laws. Fundamental to these beliefs is the idea of inherent human dignity; that all people are created in the image of God. This principle underpins our understanding of justice, respect, and equality, shaping our laws and societal norms. It’s no coincidence that our judicial systems are built around concepts like fairness, mercy, and the sanctity of life—principles rooted in the teachings of the Bible.

The Judeo-Christian ethic of “love thy neighbor” and the Golden Rule—“do unto others as you would have them do unto you”—transcends religious belief and is deeply ingrained in Western moral philosophy. Even in secular circles, these values influence how we view personal responsibility and compassion for others. They call us to self-sacrifice and moral accountability, challenging the purely individualistic mindset that modern culture often promotes. When societies stray from these core principles, we witness the consequences: ethical confusion, weakened family structures, and a loss of community bonds.

Community and Belonging: Religion as a Unifying Force

One of the most overlooked contributions of religion is the strong sense of community it fosters. Faith-based communities are not just spiritual gatherings; they are vibrant social networks that support individuals through life’s challenges, offering friendship, mentorship, and mutual care. The church is often a lifeline for those who feel lost or isolated, providing a safe space to connect with others and find support.

In the Judeo-Christian tradition, believers are encouraged to “bear one another’s burdens” (Galatians 6:2) and to serve each other through love and compassion. The charitable work undertaken by religious groups, from soup kitchens to homeless shelters, flows directly from these teachings. In times of crisis—be it a natural disaster or a personal tragedy—religious communities often mobilize to offer immediate aid, emotional support, and a shoulder to lean on. This sense of belonging and responsibility to others is something our increasingly isolated society desperately needs.

Religion’s role in community building goes beyond charity; it fosters a shared identity. Weekly services, Bible studies, prayer meetings, and religious festivals all reinforce this bond, creating a sense of unity and shared purpose. In a fragmented world, this communal aspect of religion offers a rare and valuable source of stability.

Faith as a Source of Meaning and Resilience

Religion, particularly within Judeo-Christian traditions, provides a wellspring of hope, meaning, and resilience to believers who seek purpose beyond the material world. For countless people, faith is an anchor through life’s storms, a reminder that there is something greater than the individual and that trials are often opportunities for growth and transformation. The Bible is filled with stories of perseverance and resilience, from Job’s unshakable faith in the face of suffering to Paul’s enduring spirit despite persecution. In these teachings, we find comfort and strength; they are timeless guides for those facing personal crises, grief, or uncertainty.

Judeo-Christian values uniquely emphasize the sanctity of each life, teaching that everyone is created in the image of God (Genesis 1:27). This belief instills a profound sense of purpose in individuals, affirming that each life has inherent worth and that, no matter the circumstances, one is loved and valued by a Creator. Such teachings are not only spiritually nourishing but also psychologically empowering, enabling believers to face challenges with a resilient mindset.

In times of societal upheaval, the call to "love your neighbor as yourself" (Matthew 22:39) inspires people to reach out, build connections, and find purpose beyond self-interest. Faith communities are often at the forefront of relief efforts, charitable work, and community rebuilding, particularly in the aftermath of crises. In this way, Judeo-Christian beliefs serve as an invaluable source of hope, resilience, and action in a world often overwhelmed by individualism and secularism.

Religion’s Role in Preserving Cultural Heritage and Identity

Religion also plays a critical role in preserving cultural heritage and reinforcing identity. Religious traditions—such as holidays, festivals, and rituals—link people to their history and ancestors. These practices cultivate pride and unity, fostering a sense of continuity across generations. Religion, by preserving cultural heritage, strengthens the bonds that connect individuals to their communities and past, reinforcing a sense of identity that is both enduring and meaningful.

In the case of Judeo-Christian heritage, religious celebrations such as Christmas, Easter, Passover, and Yom Kippur do more than just observe rituals; they celebrate liberation, forgiveness, renewal, and redemption—values that resonate across cultures and encourage a sense of shared history. By honoring these traditions, believers keep alive the stories, customs, and lessons of the past, ensuring that the wisdom of earlier generations is carried forward to guide and inspire future ones.

Counterargument: Religion Causes Division and Intolerance

Critics argue that religion can foster division and intolerance, especially when religious doctrines clash or when dogmatic beliefs lead to conflict. History offers many examples of religious violence, from the Crusades to contemporary sectarian violence. For some, these events underscore religion’s potential to divide societies rather than unite them, casting doubt on its role as a force for good.

Rebuttal: Religion’s Positive Influence Outweighs Instances of Misuse

While there are instances where religion has been misused to justify violence, these often arise from political motives rather than religious teachings. Most faiths promote peace, compassion, and empathy. Religious organizations worldwide work tirelessly for peacemaking, interfaith dialogue, and humanitarian relief, demonstrating religion’s potential as a force for unity and social good. When practiced authentically, religion bridges divides rather than creating them, fostering respect and cooperation. By focusing on its core values, religion serves as a powerful tool for societal harmony and moral upliftment.

Conclusion

In the face of modern challenges, religion continues to play an essential role in shaping morals, building communities, providing comfort, and preserving cultural identity. While critics may focus on instances of misuse, these pale in comparison to religion’s vast contributions to society. Far from being outdated, religion remains a cornerstone of human civilization, uniting generations, reinforcing ethical values, and inspiring hope. In a world that often emphasizes division and individualism, religion stands as a beacon of unity, strength, and compassion—values that form the backbone of a stable and resilient society.

The core teachings of Judeo-Christianity call for love, forgiveness, and compassion—qualities that counteract societal issues like selfishness, violence, and apathy. Religion reminds us that we are part of something greater than ourselves, that we have a duty to serve, protect, and uplift our communities, and that our lives are connected through a shared spiritual heritage. For those who seek peace, morality, and a higher purpose, religion remains an irreplaceable force for good in modern society.